caps roundtable: playoff edition

(photo by Brian Murphy)

Although the Washington Capitals are in Toronto this evening to take on the Maple Leafs, it’s safe to say that most D.C. sports fans have already turned their attention to the playoffs.

With three relatively meaningless games left in the regular season, the Capitals simply need to get as healthy as possible – especially on the blue line – if they’re going to finally make that postseason run that’s managed to elude this team thus far.

As the regular season comes to a close, I thought it would be fitting to reach out to some of the most respected Capitals blogs with 10 questions on the mind of every Caps fan.

Our panelists for this exercise are Neil Greenberg from Russian Machine Never Breaks, David Getz from Japers’ Rink, Dave Nichols from Caps News Network, Jack Anderson from Kings of Leonsis and the gaggle of writers from On Frozen Blog. So thanks to everyone for participating and here are the best answers from our impromptu roundtable.

1. How would you sum up the Washington Capitals’ 2010-11 regular season in one sentence?

JR: An 82-game preseason.

RMNB: The law of averages caught up to them.

OFB: Like a mediocre date: starts with a strong hello, slumps when the food is served and there’s forced conversation with a lack of energy/effort, but finally finishes on a positive note with some promise for the future.

2. Which Caps player has impressed you the most during the regular season? Why?

CNN: Michal Neuvirth. He’s shown he can handle the workload of being a starting goalie in the NHL.

KOL: Enough can’t be said about the young tandem of John Carlson and Karl Alzner. They have been rock solid with injuries hampering much of the remainder of defensive corps.

OFB: Scott Hannan. He is the player who has been forgotten this season. He plays like the team’s second best defenseman behind Dennis Wideman and looks like a solid leader.

3. In what seed will the Capitals finish the regular season?

CNN and KOL both believe the Caps will finish first. The rest of the gang voted for second place in the East.

4. Who would you like to see in round one? Why?

RMNB: Buffalo, since it looks like they will be 100 percent without goalie Ryan Miller or without a 100 percent Miller.

JR: I’d like to see the Carolina Hurricanes. From a match-up standpoint, they’re ideal because I think they’re overly reliant on Eric Staal and Cam Ward and because I don’t think their defense is good enough to stop the Capitals’ first two lines. From a schadenfreude perspective, I’d like to see Joe Corvo go out in the first round again, this time at the hands of the Caps.

CNN: I don’t care because I’m not afraid of anyone in the East. They are all too flawed in their own ways.

5. Who do you want the Capitals to avoid in round one? Why?

JR: I’d be most scared to face Buffalo, just because I think Ryan Miller’s the guy among bubble teams who could single-handedly win a series for his team. Every other facet of the game you can plan for, and I think the Capitals match up well with just about anyone, but with an elite goalie, you can only do so much.

RMNB: Boston or the New York Rangers. Both have a goalie that can get white hot and “Halak” them.

KOL: The Rangers. New York has the hottest goalie in the Eastern Conference plus a defense willing to block shots and limit opportunities. The Caps never usually respond well to a disciplined defensive front.

6. Which goalie do you want for Game 7?

RMNB and JR both pledge their allegiance to Team Varly, while CNN and KOL side with Team Neuvy. OFB, thanks to a stubborn Elisabeth, opts for Team Holtby.

7. Which non-goalie is most vital to an extended playoff run for the Caps?

JR: Nicklas Backstrom.  He’s the one guy who doesn’t have anyone behind him capable of picking up the slack if he has to miss time.

CNN: Scott Hannan. If he were to go down with injury the Caps would be in big trouble.

OFB: The man who brought Jersey Shore to the locker room: John Carlson. He has the most minutes of anyone on the team, and, if both Mike Green and Dennis Wideman stay out, he bears the shared responsibility of a top defensive pairing and additional power play minutes. Plus, he can score in pressure situations (World Juniors, anyone?)

8. Who is most likely to be the team’s breakout star of the postseason?

RMNB: Marco Sturm. He has gotten a ton of good chances but no puck luck. If that changes (and he’s healthy) he could be the difference maker.

CNN: I don’t see a “breakout” locally, but Neuvirth will get attention nationally.

KOL: If Eric Fehr’s shoulder holds up he’ll continue his knack for scoring big goals and emerge as a vital piece on the third line.

9. How far do the Caps have to advance for you to consider this season a success?

Our esteemed panelists (and Jack), all agree that it’s Eastern Conference Finals or bust for the Capitals this year.

10. Which two teams will square off in the Stanley Cup finals (with my two cents added in parenthesis)?

RMNB: Boston Bruins versus Detroit Red Wings (because Boston fans aren’t obnoxious enough).

CNN: Washington Capitals versus Vancouver Canucks (Dave’s preseason prediction).

KOL: Washington Capitals versus Detroit Red Wings (a rematch of a series Jack wasn’t alive for).

JR: San Jose Sharks versus Philadelphia Flyers (in hopes of jinxing both teams).

OFB: Washington Capitals versus Vancouver Canucks (only if Holtby is available though).


  1. NeilRMNB
    April 5, 2011 at 8:28 am


  2. Ray in Bowie
    April 5, 2011 at 8:51 am

    “The Caps never usually respond well to a disciplined defensive front.” The chronic psychosis of a Caps fan can result in using “never usually” in a sentence 🙂

  3. RAL
    April 5, 2011 at 10:38 am

    1. I hope it was worth it.
    2. Carlson. 20 year old shutdown d, thirty esp too.
    4. Agree fully with jr…plus carolina is horrible at possession.
    5. Philly. No team in the east has a group of skaters that can pitch a clinic like the Flyers.
    7. This team has exactly one skater who can win a series on his own…we all know who that is.
    10. Vancouver and philly

  4. Jack
    April 5, 2011 at 10:52 am

    Murf, I hate you.

  5. Ex KiwiKrol
    April 5, 2011 at 11:34 am

    If Jack didn’t see Esa miss an empty goal, it didn’t happen.

  6. Angie
    April 5, 2011 at 4:01 pm

    LOL! At Comment #’s 2 and 5. Very interesting perspectives here. Still trying to see the rationale for Varly other than he’s played in the playoffs before.

  7. breaklance
    April 6, 2011 at 8:59 am

    1. Like the movie Cocoon. They were playing a way that wasn’t working, changed, and evolved their play into a better team. And there is currently a strong old people movement a la Knuble.
    2. I’ll differ and go with Hendricks. Classic Cinderella story guy but he’s show he can grind like a 4rth liner, fight without becoming a bloody pulp(love ya Brads), and can score more than a 4rth liner. With the post season the grinders and secondary scoring become soo much more important.
    3. I don’t care where they finish as long as they don’t seed against the Rangers in round 1.
    4. It may not be a possibility but the Canes. Otherwise I’d have to go with Buffalo.
    5. The rangers, they are a tough disciplined team with great depth, scoring, defense, and still one of the best goalies in the league with King Henry. I look at them and see a better version of last years Canadiens.
    6. Team Tandem. I’d like to see Varly get the majority of starts but I don’t think either can handle the load of a potential 28 game post season alone.
    7. Alex Semin. Without him playing Good Sasha we have 1 scoring line and become a more predictable to defend against team. You don’t win any game scoring no goals, but to have Sasha scoring puts less pressure on Ovie and Backs with more pressure on our opponents defensive match ups.
    8. I’ll predict Eric Fehr. But I secretly desire Marcus Johansson to light up the post season faster than Burning Man.
    9. To the conference finals, and can’t be kicked out in 4 games. If we went to the finals and lost in game 6, I’d still consider this a good post season.
    10. Boston vs Nashville (for a battle of the hardest shot, and most boring to watch teams)

  8. KHtaD
    April 6, 2011 at 9:13 am


    Varly looks like the most talented goalie with even modest sample size by both ES SV% and Kareem E.’s expected SV% analysis. If he’s healthy and ready to play, I think he gives the Caps the best shot at winning on a given night. Health is his big question, though. If the Caps make a deep run, I’d count on seeing both Varly and Neuvy at some point – neither one has been an iron man back there at any point in their careers.

  9. Ben
    April 6, 2011 at 10:03 am

    9. How far do the Caps have to advance for you to consider this season a success?

    Our esteemed panelists (and Jack), all agree that it’s Eastern Conference Finals or bust for the Capitals this year.

    I’ll repeat what I said in the Japers’ comments: I do not understand or agree with this mentality. At all.

    There is not a single team in the NHL the Caps cannot beat in a 7 game series. I think most would agree. So why the hell should we be satisfied if they lose?

    You only get so many chances at a Cup; how much more can we expect from a team than the Caps have now? We’ve got great team D, PK, PP rounding into form, explosive scoring relative health, depth, a good mix of veterans and youth, experience, leadership, a coach who can adjust, two capable goalies, the best player in the world, and it’s all coming together at the right time. I mean, what the hell more can you ask of a Cup-Winning Roster?

    Accepting an exit in the Conference Finals is fucking bullshit. 23 years as a Caps fan and almost there isn’t good enough for me. Sorry.

  10. Jack
    April 6, 2011 at 1:58 pm

    I agree with Ben: if not now, when??? If you look at teams that became perennial powerhouses, they all matured together when young, good GMs picked up the missing pieces, and in 3-5 years, they are a machine for years to come (ie; the Red Wings with Yzerman). BB has done a perfect job of bringing them to the wire and GMGM has provided the pieces. JUST DO IT!!!

Leave a Reply

HomerMcFanboy background image