redskins doomed until line improves

(photo by Brian Murphy)

What if, to steal a phrase from the immortal Denny Green, the Washington Redskins are who we thought they were?

What if they really are an 8-8 team at best? What if the cupboard was truly so barren when general manager Bruce Allen and head coach Mike Shanahan took over that it really was going to take multiple seasons to turn this franchise into something resembling respectability?

On this week’s episode of Skinscast, I was down on the Redskins. Like, really down. As in, I went on record as saying that if someone could guarantee that Washington would win two of their last five games – which would mean a 7-9 season – I said I’d take it in a heartbeat.

My thought process is that there are so many areas of concern on this roster that there’s little reason to believe this team is capable of putting together a streak like 2005 or 2007 to sneak into the postseason.

Think about it – Shanahan is a two-time Super Bowl winning coach who has a history of turning ordinary running backs into 1,000-yard rushers seemingly overnight.

His son, Kyle, was the man behind the Houston Texans’ dynamic passing attack that just one season ago was best in the NFL.

His quarterback, Donovan McNabb, is a six-time Pro Bowler who easily ranks among the best at his position over the last decade.

And yet, the Redskins offense is terrible. They rank 21st in the league in yards, 25th overall in points per game and give little reason to believe when the game is on the line that they’re capable of doing anything remotely special.

Did the head coach, offensive coordinator and quarterback all suddenly forget how to play football? Did they lose their mojo simply by coming to town? Are the Redskins really that cursed?

Let’s be honest – what we’re seeing has nothing to do with the team lining up against Washington week in and week out. No, everything wrong with the burgundy and gold comes down one glaring weakness – the offensive line.

Look, it’s no secret that the former regime openly neglected the offensive line. Why draft a guard when a receiver or safety is still on the board? People don’t buy jerseys of offensive linemen, so why even bother?

Skill positions are much more enjoyable to watch film of, so it was easy for Vinny Cerrato to pause his Saturday morning cartoons to watch highlights of a raw Michigan State receiver tearing up the Big 10. I mean, doesn’t that sound way more fun than watching two fat bodies do battle in the trenches?

People don’t pay attention to that. They’d much rather see a cornerback take an interception to the house or pass catcher turn on the burners during a 40-yard bomb. So year after year the Redskins used the precious few draft picks they held onto on glamour positions. And now the franchise is paying the price.

I, by no means, claim to be an NFL talent evaluator or scout. I’m simply a guy who has stood on the sidelines for six seasons now watching the Redskins up close and personal.

As best as I can tell, the Redskins currently have one and a half offensive linemen that they can build off of.

Obviously tackle Trent Williams, the team’s top pick in the 2010 draft, is a keeper. He’s had an up and down inaugural campaign as he’s been asked to take on some of the best pass rushers the NFL – Mario Williams, Ndamukong Suh and Jared Allen in particular had little trouble getting to the quarterback – has to offer, but it’s clear the kid has skill. The longer he’s around, the better he’ll be.

Jammal Brown, the team’s right tackle, is finally starting to look healthy and, in related news, has fared much better the last few weeks as opposed to earlier this season when every time I noticed him, he was picking himself up off the ground.

He’s a guy who played at a Pro Bowl level in New Orleans, but the knock on the six-year pro is he’s never been healthy enough to play a full 16-game season. When Brown missed the entire 2009 season due to a hip injury, the Saints finally grew impatient and traded the 29-year-old to Washington for draft picks.

This season alone, Brown has been knocked out of the lineup with knee injury in the Green Bay game and a concussion in the second Philadelphia game. He’s clearly a talented player when he’s healthy, but that’s far from a given with Brown.

And yet, as far as I’m concerned, those two guys are the only bright spots on the offensive line. Things only go downhill from here.

At guard, Kory Lichtensteiger and Artis Hicks have done nothing to show that either of them should be considered a long-term solution and Derrick Dockery is obviously not a Shanahan guy. If Lichtensteiger and Hicks are your first two guys off the bench, that’s one thing. But neither inspires confidence and both guys get pushed around far too frequently.

Which brings me to center Casey Rabach. Look, I fully admit that I am a big fan of Rabach the person. By all accounts he’s a good dude and he’s always been a stand-up guy who provides great quotes. But that doesn’t mean fans should turn a blind eye to the issues this offensive line has up the middle.

When an 11-year veteran like McNabb is 50/50 to take the snap and get away from the center without being stepped on, then you know there’s a problem. At 34, the guy didn’t suddenly forget how to play the game. His offensive line is getting blown back so quickly that he’s basically got to backpeddle as quickly as possible to get out of there alive.

And let’s not forget that the Redskins’ ground game racked up 29 measly yards on 13 carries against Minnesota. Youngsters like James Davis and Keiland Williams might someday blossom into bona fide NFL studs, but with this offensive line, they were fighting just to get back to the line of scrimmage.

Think about it – Clinton Portis may or may not be done and Ryan Torain may or may not be an injury-prone player who never lives up to his potential. But the fact is, any running back with at least 25 carries under his belt this season has been knocked out of action.
That’s because this offensive line is below average by nearly any possible statistical measure. Case in point:

– Redskins quarterbacks have been sacked 32 times (tied for fifth worst in the NFL).
– According to Football Outsiders, the Redskins offensive line ranks 23rd in pass protection.
– On the same site, Washington’s offensive line ranks 25th overall in run blocking.
– Redskins running backs get stuffed 27 percent of the time, second-worst in the league (behind only Seattle).

So if you’re wondering why the Redskins have thrown more interceptions than touchdowns (13 to 11), is converting only 27 percent of their third downs or has had 12 different running backs on the roster this season, it’s because the offensive line is failing.

It’s not a coincidence that Jason Campbell goes to Oakland and suddenly guides the Raiders to their first three-game winning streak in recent history or Javarris James goes from the Redskins practice squad to touchdown machine for Indianapolis. They’re now playing on teams that acknowledge the importance of depth in the trenches.

The Colts and Raiders have each drafted 19 offensive or defensive linemen since 2004. The Redskins? Just 10.

The good news is that the front office used three of their six picks in 2010 on linemen. Sure, two of the three were seventh rounders who failed to make the 53-man roster, but progress is progress.

If Allen and Shanahan are going to turn this team around, then the priority this offseason needs to be getting younger across the board and aggressively seeking depth on the offensive line. Of course, the same could also be said about Washington’s defensive line, but we’ll save that for another day.


  1. ExKiwi Krol
    December 2, 2010 at 9:11 am

    If Jammal Brown at 500 pounds and 8 foot 14 is half a player, what does that make Brandon Banks?

    You’re right though, teams like…say…Cleveland, have been drafting lineman the last few years (who even start) and they can run the ball and occasionally pass. Now if they would only stay away from Half-Quarterbacks…..

  2. WildBill1952
    December 2, 2010 at 6:21 pm

    I have said the same thing (although admittedly not as well) for years. The sins of the past have come back to haunt the Redskins. Whether it was 100% Vinny, Snyder, or a combination of both of them with some coaches thrown in, no longer matters. This is now Shanny’s and Allen’s team. It will be interesting to see if they have the patience, and the Kahunas, to withstand the wrath of Redskin Nation as they bypass the glory picks of skill players in the draft and instead build a winner by picking up some boring OL in the draft.

  3. fusion
    December 2, 2010 at 10:10 pm

    javarris james having just 2 touchdowns makes him a touchdown machine? and indianapolis and oakland have a good offensive line? manning makes indy’s line look better than what they really are, and lets not even start on oakland’s offensive line lol

  4. b murf
    December 3, 2010 at 10:12 am

    Fusion, James currently has three touchdowns in 22 carries. I’d say that’s pretty good. Oh, and the Colts are ranked best in the NFL by Football Outsiders in pass protection. Spin it how you want, but that says they’re getting the job done.

  5. Arthur
    December 3, 2010 at 11:46 am

    Isn’t it great that after 10 years of misery, little Danny has reportedly learned the very first thing every other NFL front office guy learned on his first day on the job? Everyone knows you build the lines first.

    But honestly, I’ll believe it when I see it. He already wasted draft picks trading for McNabb. McNabb’s great — over-the-hill and limited, but great — but this team didn’t need an aging QB. They need those draft picks.

    This Spring, we’ll hear that the Skins need a receiver, and a running back, and a safety, and a lot of linebackers, and a defensive tackle. Forget all that. The Skins need offensive linemen.

    That means they won’t be good next year, either. I doubt little Danny has the patience for that. I think he’ll win the offseason yet again, signing Pro Bowlers to fat contracts that they’ll never live up to.

    I would never wish for anyone to die, but if a bus hit Danny today, wouldn’t we have to hold a parade?

Leave a Reply

HomerMcFanboy background image