redskins made a mistake by not trading away kirk cousins

(photo by Brian Murphy)

I can’t help but think that the Washington Redskins missed a chance to improve their football team this week, when they failed to pull the trigger on a trade before the deadline.

No, I’m not talking about tight end Fred Davis, who – for reasons that remain unclear – has become a complete afterthought this season.

I’m talking about backup quarterback Kirk Cousins.

Sure, he’s a stand-up guy and a football franchise can never have enough depth at quarterback – especially when the starter is coming off of major knee surgery.

And yet, if I was the guy calling the shots at Redskins Park, I would have called the Cleveland Browns every day for the last few weeks until they agreed to a deal involving second-year receiver Josh Gordon coming to town in exchange for Cousins.

Because, for as much of a savior as some ‘Skins fans apparently think Cousins is, his actual body of work since Washington utilized a fourth-round pick in the 2012 draft for him isn’t all that impressive.

Let’s review what he’s done up to this point:

  • Cousins made his NFL debut in relief duty after franchise quarterback Robert Griffin III was knocked out of action against the Atlanta Falcons Week 5. The Michigan State product completed five of nine passes for 111 yards with one touchdown and two interceptions.
  • Two months later, Cousins was arguably at his best as he sparked a comeback victory over the Baltimore Ravens after RGIII was once again forced out of the game due to injury. That being said, Cousins only completed two passes on the day for 26 yards, but one of those passes resulted in a touchdown and he followed it up with a two-point conversion that ultimately enabled the Redskins to emerge victorious.
  • One week later, Cousins made his first-career start against the Browns in Cleveland. Although he started poorly that game, the 25-year-old completed 26 of 37 passes for 329 yards with two touchdowns and one interception in a 38-21 victory.
  • And then there was the infamous playoff game against the Seattle Seahawks, where many ‘Skins fans and experts firmly believe Cousins should have replaced an injured and ineffective RGIII much earlier. Of course, once he did finally make his way onto the field, Cousins wasn’t any better than his one-legged counterpart – going three for 10 for 31 yards with no touchdowns and no interceptions.
  • Finally, we’ve got last week’s fourth quarter cameo – where Cousins once again filled in for Griffin – and completed five of nine passes with no touchdowns and two interceptions.

For his career, Cousins has completed 41 of 67 passes (61 percent) for 545 yards with four touchdowns and five interceptions with a quarterback rating of 75.7.

Those stats, over the course of a season, roughly translate to what Carson Palmer is producing in Arizona or Chad Henne has done in Jacksonville this season. His completion percentage would place Cousins around 16th in the league and the quarterback rating would land him at 26th. In other words, simply looking at the numbers, Cousins appears to be serviceable, at best, to this point in his young career.

Should anyone rush to judgment after five brief appearances? Of course not. I’m just suggesting that there is a possibility that Cousins might not actually be the mythical being that a faction of the local fanbase seems convinced he is.

With that in mind, I would have happily dealt Cousins to the quarterback-starved Browns – who were last seen trotting out Jason Campbell (yes, THAT Jason Campbell) at the NFL’s most vital position.

It’s no secret that Cleveland is going through a rebuilding phase. They already dealt running back Trent Richardson to Indianapolis earlier this season and have basically let it be known that other players – including Gordon – are available, if the price is right.

And this is where the Redskins should have done everything within their power to acquire Gordon. Why? Because he’s a playmaker with a skill set the burgundy and gold is desperately lacking. He’s got great hands, always finds ways to get separation from defenders and stretches the field with his uncanny knack for hauling in bombs – even when guys like Campbell or Brandon Weeden are prominently involved.

Up to this point, this might come across as an out of touch blogger caught up in some sort of fantasy football world. I get that. But let me explain why I feel like this is a deal that could of, and more importantly, should have happened.

For starters, the Browns general manager is a guy named Mike Lombardi. Before taking over that position, Lombardi was a regularly writer for

With that in mind, I would like to turn your attention to this particular column Lombardi wrote last December in which he said that Redskins offensive coordinator Kyle Shanahan and Cousins could make for an enticing package for a rebuilding franchise.

Here’s an excerpt:

“Whenever a coach can take two rookie quarterbacks and produce positive results, he must be given strong consideration. … However, his work with Cousins in last week’s crucial win over the Cleveland Browns has made everyone in the league stand up and notice — especially those teams in dire need of a quarterback and a coach. … Any team that hires Shanahan as its next coach might be able to pry away Cousins for a modest price — considering he was just a fourth-round pick in last April’s draft — addressing two huge problems at once.”

So I don’t think it’s a stretch to say he’s a fan of what he’s seen from Cousins thus far. But wait – there’s more. Here is a link to a mailbag Mary Kay Cabot, of the The Plain Dealer, did back in February.

Hey, Mary Kay: Why isn’t Redskins quarterback Kirk Cousins on the Browns’ radar as possible competition for Brandon Weeden? I think he fits the new offensive scheme. I would think he could be had if the price isn’t too steep.

Hey, Vince: With Robert Griffin III coming off reconstructive knee surgery, there’s no way the Redskins would part with Cousins. It was obvious last season how important it is for teams with dual-threat QBs to have a capable backup. Cousins, the Redskins’ fourth-round pick last April, completed 26 of 37 attempts for 329 yards with two touchdowns and an interception en route to a 38-21 victory over the Browns. Pat Shurmur really liked the former Michigan State product, but the Browns opted for Weeden instead.

Shurmur, it should be noted, was the head coach of the Browns last season. So even if he’s no longer there, for the purpose of this discussion we’ve now got a head coach and a general manager in Cleveland who both like Cousins. Just as importantly, there’s the fact that Griffin and Gordon know each other quite well from their time together at Baylor.

In related news, NFL insider Jason La Canfora reported just before the 2012 Supplemental Draft that “RG3 is pushing the Redskins brass hard to land Gordon in tomorrow’s draft.”

Here we are, a year and a half later and Griffin still desperately needs another go-to option to turn to in this offense. Sure, he’s got receiver Pierre Garcon, rookie tight end Jordan Reed and running back Alfred Morris, but Gordon can stretch the field in a way that mediocre wideouts like Leonard Hankerson and Aldrick Robinson can only dream of –- which is why he’s worth the risk of trading away one of the league’s better backups.

Case in point: since the bye week, here’s the production the Redskins have gotten from their pass catchers over their last three game:

Garcon: targeted 34 times with 18 catches (52 percent) for 173 yards with zero touchdowns.
Reed: targeted 29 times with 21 catches (72 percent) for 282 yards with one touchdown.
Moss: targeted nine times with four catches (44 percent) for 62 yards with zero touchdowns.
Hankerson: targeted 14 times with four catches (28 percent) for 69 yards with one touchdown.
Morgan: targeted three times with two catches (66 percent) for 9 yards with zero touchdowns.
Robinson: targeted four times with two catches (50 percent) for 75 yards with one touchdowns.

Clearly teams are going out of their way to take away Garcon, which is why Reed has suddenly emerged as RGIII’s new favorite target. But none of the other receivers listed has been able to make themselves relevant this season, which is why no receiver on the roster has visited the endzone more than cornerback DeAngelo Hall, who has three touchdowns through seven games.

So yeah, that’s why I think the Redskins made a mistake by not shipping Cousins off to Cleveland. Even if they had to sweeten the deal with a draft pick in order to land Gordon, it should have been a no brainer. By giving Griffin more dependable options to turn to, you increase his chances of succeeding on Sundays, which in turn helps to keep defenses from teeing off on him like ‘Skins fans saw in the second half of the Denver debacle.

Landing Gordon could have gone a long way towards keeping Griffin healthy and happy. Unfortunately, the current regime was either unwilling or unable to do what was necessary to make this fantasy become a reality.


  1. insanenun
    October 31, 2013 at 11:00 am

    I stopped reading when you said ‘for Josh Gordon’. Nah, just kidding, but seriously.

    If Josh Gordon keeps his head straight, he is could be one of the better receivers in the league, and the Browns have seen plenty of shitty receivers to see a good one when they pop up.

    Is Cousins > Gordon in the Brown’s eyes? I hope not. Their offense changed dramatically once he came back.

  2. insanenun
    October 31, 2013 at 11:02 am

    Cleveland’s offense that is. It was less ‘offensive’ if you get what I mean.

  3. Joel
    October 31, 2013 at 12:16 pm

    What drugs are you on? They sound amazing.

    RGIII has been unable to make it through all 16 games in his two seasons in the NFL. And he hasn’t exactly been lighting it up on the field this season.

    Cousins has looked good being thrust into rough situations with very little practice time. You know as well as anyone that the backup doesn’t get many snaps in practice, so the fact that he has middle of the pack numbers without getting the reps is impressive to me. Imagine what he could do if he was actually the starter. (I have to imagine that the team’s record would be better right now if Cousins had been playing in the first few games instead of Griffin.)

    Why would you throw that away to get a receiver? One guy isn’t going to fix the problems the Redskins are having right now (unless that guy is a defensive coordinator/special teams coach). So you are essentially arguing that you would throw away depth at the most important position in football to slightly improve the offense, which is only one-third (and possibly the smallest) of the problems the team is having right now.

  4. Jeff
    November 1, 2013 at 9:31 am

    Joel, one good game against Cleveland does not a Tom Brady make. I’d gladly trade away a security blanket off the field for a noticeable improvement ON the field. The only problem is that teams aren’t paying a high price for Cousins mid season. You don’t trade high value players midseason for a guy unless he is the difference between a playoff run and not one. Unless you are the Vikings, a serviceable but not elite QB isn’t that missing piece. Add in the recent Cassell and Flynn suckfests and you have a situation where no team in the league is going to want to drop 2nd rnd of better payouts for a backup QB with a limited on field body of work. Come the offseason, KCs value may shoot back up towards 2nd rnder, depending on who comes out of college. That will be the time to cute a deal for some picks.

Leave a Reply

HomerMcFanboy background image