when is a goal not a goal?

(photo by Francois Lacasse)

When it comes to officiating, there is nothing more vital than consistency.

Regardless of the sport, referees owe it to the teams playing the game and the fans watching the game to interpret the rules with consistency.

We bring this up because the defining moment of the Washington Capitals 6-5 loss to the Montreal Canadiens yesterday was a questionable disallowed goal.

With less than six minutes remaining in the second period, the Capitals looked to have scored a momentum-changing goal to pull within one, at 4-3. Caps forward Alex Ovechkin destroyed Habs defenseman Hall Gill, who crash landed into goalie Carey Price as the puck slipped into the net. Here’s the video:

Now, let’s go back in time to April 22, 2008. Skip ahead to the 2:30 mark of this next video and watch what transpires:

In both instances, an offensive player hits a defensive player into his own goalie. In both instances, the play goes against the Capitals. When a Philadelphia player delivers the hit (in the playoffs, no less), the play is ruled legal. When a Washington player delivers the hit, it was initially ruled a goal and then waved off without any further explanation.

Folks wonder why Caps fans have some kind of inferiority complex and are convinced the world is against them. Well, we definitely don’t think this call intentionally went against the Capitals, but these are the plays that are turned to when those arguments are made.

If it’s a goal in 2008, then it should be a goal now. Unless the rules have been changed. And if that’s the case, we probably should have heard about it by now.The NFL changes their rules every time Tom Brady get a boo boo, but at least they have the common courtesy to inform us about it up front.

Consistency shouldn’t be optional. It should be what the league office strives for. It should be what officials are graded on. And, most importantly, it should be applied in hopes of restoring what little sanity we have left.


  1. DC Landing Strip
    February 11, 2010 at 3:30 pm

    Further proof that the playoffs are a different beast!

  2. Mike
    February 12, 2010 at 9:38 am

    About time someone put these two videos right next to each other. Thanks!

  3. ilan
    February 12, 2010 at 11:34 am

    Nice post, I hope Mike Murphy sees it.

  4. Caps Nut
    February 12, 2010 at 1:02 pm

    It should also be noted that the NHL issued an official statement after Game 7 stating the officials on the ice made the correct call.


    You are correct that no changes to the rules regarding these situations have occurred since then and the NHL has yet to offer an explanation for what happened on Wednesday night.

Leave a Reply

HomerMcFanboy background image